Skip to main content

FHT shareholders - The fine line between wisdom and greed

Frasers Hospitality Trust shares fell from $0.70 to $0.54 (nearly a 25% drop) on 13 Sep 2022 following a failed privatisation bid by its parent company. 

To be fair, it was a close call, with 74.88% of shareholders voting in favor of the deal, falling narrowly short of the 75% approval threshold.

Ostensibly, the remaining 25.12% shareholders thought the offer of 70 cents to be undervaluing FHT's assets. 

The main complaint here appears to be that privatisation offer was opportunistic and low-balling, especially given that FHT's prospects seem to be improving as more and more countries treat covid as endemic and re-open their borders.

Now, one has to wonder whether those who voted against the deal were overly optimistic on FHT's prospects and missed out a chance to cash out at, what i thought was, a fair price for FHT.

To be clear, I am invested in Frasers Property Limited, and was indeed quite nonplussed at the privatisation offer, which (in my opinion) was essentially bailing out investors from a languishing FHT at the expense of FPL.  Thus, I am not entirely upset with the offer falling through. 



The fact is FHT's DPU had been steadily falling way before the pandemic struck. For FY2019, FHT's DPU was 4.4129 cents.  Indeed the DPU fell quite consistently at 6% each year between 2016 - 2019.

The question for me is, even if there was no pandemic, what would FHT's DPU have looked like? In the best case scenario, it might be maintained at 2019 levels. Or you know, it could have continued to fall 6% a year to around 3.9 cents in 2021.

At the privatisation offer price of $ 0.70, FHT's yield would be slightly over 6.3% assuming DPU recovered to 2019 levels, which in my view, is unlikely.  Conversely, if FHT's hospitality assets had continued to underperform and DPU fell below 4 cents, then paying $0.70 a share would be significantly overpaying for the assets.  

Ask yourself, if you were an investor, would you pay 70 cents for FHT if the DPU was 3.9 cents or even 4.4 cents? I wouldn't.  

All in all, the privatisation offer appeared to be rather fair to me.  Now that the shareholders have spurned the advances of FPL, one has to hope that there would be a miraculous recovery in store for FHT. Only time will tell. 

If not, the nay-voters might rue the day they decided to leave cash on the table to chase a recovery pipedream. 

Onward to FI my friends.






Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

As a Dividend Investor - I am having fun staying poor

Recently, there was a self-styled "master" who went around dissing dividend investing, saying things like REITS will chibaboom (his words not mine). Ironically, the master also invested into "growth stocks" like BABA and notably SE before its recent implosion.  Masterstrokes indeed. Dividend/income investors have borne the brunt of "have fun staying poor" taunts since the dawn of time.  Previously from the crypto bros and then from the growth investors. This is nothing new.  Every growth investor likes to talk about Tesla. But where are the ARK ETF investors? Where are the NIO bulls? Where are the BABA fanatics? Even a broken clock is right twice a day.   Good luck to those who retired on a portfolio of "growth stocks", hoping to spend 4% annually on an expected annualized portfolio growth rate of 10%.  Without dividends, one would have no choice but to liquidate part of the portfolio for meeting expenditures.  The damage done might never be reco...
13 comments
Read more

The FI Checklist

You are on the verge.  So close your ears are tingling with anticipation.  Your fingertips rattle across the keyboard. Your lips purse into a wry smile. You can barely contain the pent-up ecstasy as the words appear on your computer screen: "... I would like to resign my position with effect from.... " WAIT A MINUTE.  I know you have literally waited a decade to type this letter.  But hold your horses first.  Have you done the FI checklist? The FI Checklist 1.  Have you set aside a cash buffer for income tax payments, which will persist for at least one more year in your unemployed life?   Since you would no longer have an active income, it is pertinent that you have set aside sufficient cash reserves to meet your tax obligations. If your passive income level is high enough to cover your expenses plus taxes, good on you. If not, prudence dictates that you ring fence some money for Singapore's most powerful debt collector. ...
4 comments
Read more

Is it finally the end of the tunnel for REITs

General Mood Market is expecting interest rates to hold after US CPI data came out on 14 November and pointed to softening prices across the board. Oil has also retreated nearly 20% since its recent peak in Sep 2023.  Are we finally reaching the end of the tunnel for battered REIT assets?  My gut tells me that we are at early stages of recovery although we may possibly still see a couple more rate hikes in 2024.  Nonetheless, barring further escalation of global military conflicts and an unmitigated collapse of the Chinese housing market, both of which seem unlikely but can never be completely ruled out, we may start to see a gradual recovery in DPU for REITs (as rental reversions go up but interest expenses stay constant or go down).    What I did in 2023 (Not to be construed as recommendations or investment advice.) Throughout 2023, I have continued to load up on REITs which (i feel) have:      i. Good sponsors (Capland, Frasers, Maple family) ...
2 comments
Read more